Terry Comacho

11 Prospect Avenue

Shelter Island Heights, NY
$ 2,595,000 Beds 4 Baths 2.5 Sq 1,994
Monthly Estimate* How much can I afford?

Shelter Island Heights Icon Gracefully positioned in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this timeless residence has been thoughtfully renovated and restored to honor its original character while seamlessly incorporating today's modern comforts. Rich in architectural charm and classic detail, the home offers an elegant blend of historic beauty and refined living. A gracious, oversized covered porch welcomes you upon arrival, providing the perfect setting to relax and enjoy the property's elevated position and picturesque water views. Inside, a warm and inviting foyer opens to beautifully proportioned living spaces, where natural light, period details, and a sense of understated sophistication create an atmosphere of effortless elegance. Toward the rear of the home, a formal dining room and well-appointed kitchen serve as the heart of the residence. Expansive windows and French doors bathe the interiors in natural light while creating a seamless connection to the surrounding landscape and outdoor living spaces. The second level is highlighted by a spacious primary suite featuring a generously sized bath, accompanied by two well-appointed guest bedrooms designed for comfort and privacy. The third floor offers a versatile retreat, ideal as a media room, den, home office, or additional gathering space for family and guests. Outside, the beautifully landscaped grounds provide a private sanctuary framed by mature trees and established plantings, creating a tranquil setting for relaxation and entertaining alike. Ideally situated just moments from the coveted Shelter Island Heights Beach Club, tennis courts, golf, marinas, shops, and beloved local restaurants, this exceptional offering presents a rare opportunity to own a meticulously restored home in one of Shelter Island's most desirable and historic neighborhoods.

Single Family

  • Price
  • $ 2,595,000
  • City
  • Shelter Island Heights
  • Bedrooms
  • 4
  • Full Bathrooms
  • 2
  • County
  • SUFFOLK
  • Half Bathrooms
  • 1
  • Area
  • Lot Size
  • 0.12 Acres
  • Zip
  • 11965
  • Sqr Footage
  • 1,994
  • Year Built
  • 1890
  • Taxes
  • $ 8215
  • Style
  • Victorian
  • MLS#
  • 1022345
Listed By: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Data Source: Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Features

General

Sewer Public Sewer
Heating Propane
Cooling Central Air
Utilities Sewer Connected,Water Connected
Appliances Cooktop,Dishwasher,Dryer,Oven,Refrigerator,Washer
HOA Fee 6607
Garage Spaces 1
Association Fee Includes Sewer,Water
Architectural Style Victorian
Construction Materials Clapboard
Year Built 1890
Property Subtype Single Family Residence
Tax Year 2025
Parcel Number 0700-006-00-02-00-002-000
Assoc Fee Paid Per Annually
County Suffolk County
Property Type Residential
Association Amenities Clubhouse
HOA Yes
Garage Y/N Yes
Total Rooms 4
Full Baths 2
High School Shelter Island School
City Shelter Island
Senior Community Y/N No
High School District Shelter Island
Carport Y/N No
Elementary School Shelter Island School
Property Attached Y/N No
Tax Annual Amount 8215
Middle/Junior High School Shelter Island School
Additional Parcels Y/N No
Building Area Units Square Feet
Standard Status Active
Middle/Junior School District Shelter Island
Elementary School District Shelter Island
PostalCity Shelter Island Heights
AttributionContact 631-725-0200
Listing Appliances Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer

Interior Features

Interior Amenities Breakfast Bar,Entrance Foyer,Formal Dining,High Ceilings,Kitchen Island,Washer/Dryer Hookup
Basement Partial,Unfinished
Flooring Hardwood
Total Fireplaces 2
Formal Dining Yes
Basement Features Partial, Unfinished
Basement (Y/N) Yes
Fireplace Y/N Yes
Half Baths 1
Total Bedrooms 4
Total Baths 3
General Features Breakfast Bar,Entrance Foyer,Formal Dining,High Ceilings,Kitchen Island,Washer/Dryer Hookup
Entrance Foyer Yes

Exterior Features

Parking Features Garage
Water Source Public
Total Parking 1
Parking Spaces 1
Parking Features Garage
Building Area Total 1994
Waterfront Y/N No

Amenities

  • Foreclosure
  • Views
  • Short Sale
  • New Construction
  • Adult 55+
  • Lease To Own
  • No HOA Fees
  • Furnished
  • Primary On Main
  • Air Conditioning
  • Seller Finance
  • Green
  • Fixer Upper
  • Horse
  • Golf
  • Fireplace
  • Deck
  • Garage
  • Basement
  • Pool

Affordability Calculator

$3,786

Per Month

Based on the average sale price from the Bay Shore, NY office

  • Monthly Principal & interest $2,658
  • Monthly Property Taxes $1,062
  • Monthly Home Insurance $67
Adjust Payment Options
Agent Photo

Let's determine your purchasing power. Working with my mortgage partner, you'll have the information you need to shop for a home with confidence.

Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA, or jumbo loans.

Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.

Schools

Elementary School Shelter Island School Elementary School
Middle School Shelter Island School Middle School
High School Shelter Island School High School

Price History

7/7/2026 Listed $2,595,000

Property vs Zip Code Average in 11965

Price
AVG $2.53M
$2.6M
Taxes
AVG $10,869
$8,215
Year Built
AVG 1922
1890
Visits
AVG 11
22
Data Provided by Inside Real Estate®

Areas That We Cover

11 Prospect Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY is a Single Family Home for sale at $2595000 with 1994 sqft and a lot size of 0.12 Acres Acre(s). 11 Prospect Avenue Shelter Island Heights has 4 bedrooms, 2 baths and was built in 1890. The property's zip code is 11965 which is in Shelter Island Heights, NY

*Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Financial calculator disclaimer: Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.

Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.

All information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed, and should be independently verified. The real estate information and related content displayed on this site is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Terry Comacho

Terry Comacho

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

631-671-4834

By pressing Contact Me, you agree that Weichert® may contact you via phone about your inquiry, which may involve the use of automated means. You are not required to consent as a condition of purchasing any property, goods or services. For any other information please read our Privacy Policy